Sunday, 12 August 2012

Response to CILIP E-Book Policy

I spent a very enjoyable hour yesterday eating lemon meringue ice cream while sitting in a field and reading CILIP's policy document on e-books and e-lending. Sometimes it's nice just to be outside in the sunshine and luckily I have plenty of fields to choose from.



I love the amount of press e-books are getting at the moment and the publishing of this document (two in fact, there are long and short versions) is a statement in itself that the subject is being taken seriously. However at the same time the policy  briefing (I read the full version) made me a bit cross. One page in and I started wishing I'd brought a red pen with me. However I'm going to be constructive, obviously CILIP has put the documentation out for comment for a reason.

I was disappointed that more wasn't made of the convergence of the academic and public  models. E-book delivery is developing rapidly. While it was once true that the academic models favored online reading and the public demanded downloads increasingly we are seeing hybrid systems that deliver both. Touched on briefly in the policy I believe that this convergence will eventually take us to a single model for all types of e-books regardless of sector. For current examples see Ebrary's Apps  and Overdrive's browser based READ Platform, both companies that while mainly associated with one sector/delivery method are increasingly working across both. 
In terms of the policy my point is that this convergence is happening now and while some aspects of academic and public e-lending will remain fundamentally different  the delivery platform will not. Increasingly suppliers are working with both academic and public sectors and it makes economic sense to develop platforms that can be used across both. Rather than looking back at what has always been done we need to make sure that we are looking  forward and paying attention to the cutting edge of e-book delivery. I don't believe the policy does this as it stands. 

As a user of Dawson Era I was also disappointed not to see it's purchase/subscription offer listed in the appendix. (Page 17, part 2) In fact I think more investigation needs to go into this list as it seems a bit incomplete. In terms of the Dawson model, books are purchased with a number of credits and each use (download or online) deducts a set amount of these credits. Once the credits run down to zero you have to buy another copy. While I'll admit to be being bias about Dawson Era I do believe that this credit system offers a more sustainable way of lending e-books for both libraries and the publisher/rights holder. It's more flexible than the 26 loans per copy license favored by some publishers and allows credit to be set individually for each book giving publishers a number of different options when it comes to setting prices.

In more general terms I agree with the policy and what it stands for. I have, as ever, my own comment on some subjects that I've outlined below but in general it provides a good overview of the current situation. It also outlines some developments I wasn't aware of, for example the EBLIDA e-book campaign. This in particular highlights that e-books are bigger than individual services, bigger really than individual countries. Their very nature means they have to be a global concern and as such need to be addressed at a global level. An EBLIDA campaign is a step towards this, as is the recent commitment from WLIC '12 that the IFLA will work together internationally on e-books. 

To round up my views on a few subjects without embarking on an essay:
  • The rapid advances in technology over the past few decade means that legislations, such as PLR, copyright and the 1964 Act are no longer fit purpose. Amendments must be made (and enforced!)  to protect rights holders and allow libraries to continue with their business. To achieve this the government will have to be part of the conversation, however........
  • short of creating a national depository of e-books there is little the government can bring to the table when it comes to finding a resolution between authors, publishers and libraries. You may say that I am naive but e-books are business, not politics. A solution must be determined by market forces and financial feasibility otherwise it won't be sustainable. 
  • While libraries may have to compromise on some issues I believe strongly that a charge for e-books is a charge for a core library service and is not acceptable. However I also understand that there is precedent for charging in public libraries, for example audio books. Hard pressed public libraries need new sources of income and while I don't condone charging I would rather see it for e-books than services such as internet access. Of course in academic libraries charging shouldn't even be considered as students are already paying for the resources in the form of tuition fees. 
  • Forcing patrons to physically visit libraries to borrow e-books is likely to be a deciding nail in the coffin for library e-book services. We might as well give up now. While there is precedent in some academic licenses the trend has been for libraries to move away from on site only access in favor of remote. Arguments of protecting footfall only demonstrates a blinkered and out dated view of what constitutes a library 'visit.' Ultimately there will be to many other, more convenient ways, to purchase or borrow e-books, either legally or illegally, that patrons will turn to if they are forced make a physical visit. I bought a Sony E-Reader because it allowed me to borrow books from my library. If I had to go to the library to do this I'd just buy a Kindle instead.
Lastly I would like to comment on something not raised in the policy but touched on in CILIP's Communities Information and Advice Blog. It raises the feasibility of regional, or even a single national, depositories of e-books for public library users. Although some might argue for a single system I can't help but think that we need a number of different ones to encourage innovative design and use. With library consortia already established across the country I would place my vote for regional catalogues of e-books, large enough to have significant spending power while still being able to tailor purchases to their communities. Many consortia are going down this route for their LMS and acquisition services so an extension to e-books would be natural.

To round up I'll say that the important bit is what comes next, how we use the policy and how we move forward. When it comes to future proofing our library services e-books are a big deal. What ever happens we need to make sure we get it right.

And in case anyone is interested the lemon meringue ice cream came from Fearnley's on Scout Road in Bolton. It's really very good if you are in the area.


Friday, 3 August 2012

23 Things - Signing Off

I've been posting updates to my original 23 Things blog entry as comments. I'd like to say they were regular but that wouldn't be entirely truthful. 
http://jennyscabinetofcuriosities.blogspot.co.uk/2012/02/23-things.html
I've reached a point where doing 23 Things as well as Chartership has become a real struggle. I've also found that I've already done many things on the list or intend to do them as part of my PPDP. With some, as in the case with Week 6, (organising) I have  found solutions which better suit my need, for example Skydrive.
For example:
Things I have already done some of:

Week 5 - (18th July) Online Networks / Real Life Networks
  • Thing 6: Online networks (LinkedIn, Facebook, LISNPN, LATNetwork, CILIP Communities) 
  • Thing 7: National/Regional groups, Special interest groups and looking outside the library sphere
Week 7 - (1st August) Librarianship training options 
  • Thing 10: Graduate traineeships, Masters degrees, Chartership, Accreditation
  • Thing 11: Mentoring
Week 11 - (29th August) Getting involved
  • Thing 15: Attending, presenting at and organising seminars, conferences and other events
  • Thing 16: Advocacy, speaking up for the profession and getting published.
Week 16 - (3rd October) Promoting yourself in job applications and at interview
  • Thing 21: How to identify your strengths, how to capitalise on your interests, how to write something eyecatching that meets job specs. 
  • Thing 22: Volunteering to get experience 

The only Thing left that I really have a great deal of interest/passion about is Thing 20 which explores a day in the life of a library. Maybe this is cheating, maybe I should invest the time to complete the 23 Things fully. However I feel that I have to focus myself on Chartership and use the limited time I have available to me to make progression with this. I am trying to do to much (not just in terms of my CPD - I am also training for a half marathon in September) 
Therefore I have decided to call a halt to my very slow progress with 23 Things. The exception with this will be that I will attempt over the next few weeks to do a diary entry for one day per week at work on the blog. I might even submit something to CILIP for Update depending on how it turns out.

So that's me signing off from 23 Things... Maybe see you again next year when I hopefully will be Chartered. 

Tuesday, 24 July 2012

Some musings on E-Books (amongst other things) from 4 years ago!

While looking through some old work I came across this article I wrote after attending the Public Libraries Conference on a sponsored place  in 2008. I'll admit I wasn't as clued up on new technology as I am now but wow, have we come a long way since then. It was originally intended for Update but I don't think it ever got published. Can't imagine why.

" The day when public libraries worry over their choice of e book format (Sony Reader, Kindle, ibok?) may seem very remote to some. But this was just one of many forward thinking topics at this years PLA conference in Liverpool. Personally I jumped on the ‘not in the next ten years’ band wagon but having  given the subject a bit of thought it is easy to see James Bond style ‘ this book will self destruct in 14 days’  loans being common place in under a decade. After all, 20 years ago few would have fully predicted the impact of the internet on library services or the role that mobile devices play in our everyday lives. Who are we, a generation of (in the main) digital immigrants, to second guess what the public, with it’s ever increasing demographic of digital natives, will expect from their libraries.


Pursuing new formats will invariable mean choices which may or may not take us further from our traditional role of libraries. An e-book is, after all, still a book, that sacred object at the core of all library services.  Yet its existence as an electronic object takes us further from the idea of a library as a physical place and closer to the idea of a virtual entity.
"This idea of choices, or at least the consequences of choices, leads me to the second most tangible thing I brought away from this years PLA conference. In the current climate some choices are harder than others and it was obvious that many services had hard decisions to make. However what we saw at PLA  was a showcase of all the positive outcomes that have resulted  from people making the right decisions. Schemes that had services working with banks to improve numeracy in children, volunteer schemes to engage asylum seekers and true community engagement to determine how best a refurbishment of a local library might benefit it’s local residents showed positive outcomes that complimented rather than challenged reading as the central role of the library service.
While it was natural that services should want to celebrate their achievements I wasn’t the only one who commented that many speakers steered clear of more controversial issues. Some might say this is only to be expected given the presence of those people with the power to make decisions. Who after all wants to rock the boat when there is so much good to talk about ? But who would have thought it possible to present on public private partnerships without touching on that omnipresent, and high contentional,  entity – the coffee chain. Obviously by its very nature this was never going to be a conference that challenged the establishment, after all it was the establishment that was present.
 Yet while the reviews were encouraging  one has to wonder whether they will have any real impact when those responsible struggle even to decide on the benchmarks or have little real power when it comes to influencing hard up councils making spending cuts."

Monday, 23 July 2012

PLR Raises It's Head Again.

After being away for a couple of weeks, literally cut off from Twitter and the internet, it was nice to return to this Guardian article picking up on the PLR / volunteer libraries issue and also featuring library campaigner Johanna Anderson. (Admit briefly) I don't think it's the best article I've ever read, it seems a bit disjointed, but it got my brain cells ticking again after nearly two weeks of sun, sea and tequilla!

A lot more could have been said about the issues surrounding volunteer libraries, I'm sure Johanna had plenty to say that was edited out. I have several problems with the trend, some personal -  seeing experienced ex-colleagues made redundant and replaced with volunteers is soul destroying - but also many more professional ones:
  • I believe strongly that there is no substitute for trained, paid staff, both peri-professional and professional and that as result services and stock quality will ultimately suffer.
  • I believe by expecting volunteers to run what are essentially small businesses you are asking for legal and financial issues. (Budgets, FOI and child protection being just a few) 
  • After working closely with the Citizens Advice Bureau, an organisation that relies heavily on volunteers, I have seen first hand just how patchy this service can become when said volunteers decide they have other commitments or just want to go on holiday. 
This said the meat of the article is specifically about PLR payments. Although I rarely agree with the DCMS I can see their point in the final paragraph, in brief saying that the volunteer run libraries will not alter PRL payments. If we assume that the volunteer community libraries will have a similar lending profile to those council run libraries used for the PLR sample then removing them from the PLR calculations will not alter the payments received by individual authors. I made a similar point in a previous blog post about PLR and elending.
This of course assumes that the lending profile will remain similar to that in libraries where book selection is carried out by professionals and where there is a requirement to maintain a "healthy" stock covering a wide range of subject areas. I personally think it is much more likely that where volunteers are purchasing stock it will become biased towards certain areas. I also can't help but wonder if the DCMS, in the future, will use the reduction of council run libraries as another excuse to cut the overall PLR budget which would ultimately reduce payments to authors.

More worryingly is the question of copyright infringement raised by the article and the Society of Authors. The SoA are questioning whether these "Big Society" libraries are allowed to lend books at all. If they are not covered by the blanket agreement of the PLR it would be up to individual authors to give permission for their books to be lent at individual libraries- surely a difficult and unwieldy process for the most well run of libraries to manage. If the claim is upheld, as far as I can determine, it means that these Big Society libraries will be operating illegally.
I'm sure this story will unfold, hopefully with someone actually taking the legal action threatened by the SoA. It's not that I want these volunteer libraries to fail, doing so would leave some communities with no library service at all.  But it needs to be understood that libraries have been run by paid, professional staff for years for a reason, that councils cannot expect to maintain the same level of service without professional leadership or by replacing paid front line staff with volunteers.  As with other action taken by library campaigners it also demonstrates just how poorly thought through the volunteer libraries have been in some areas. Councils have made fast,  ill informed decisions to slash budgets without investigating all the ramifications of their actions, actions which it seems, may not be entirely legal.

Thursday, 5 July 2012

Chartership Chat 3rd July

Tuesday's Chartership Chat had been arranged at short notice and it had no specific topic. However as normal there were plenty of people participating, some through the whole hour and some popping in and out as other commitments allowed. We even had someone from the US. 
In summary the points covered were:

  • Our expected completion dates and our current progress. Many people commented that they were struggling to fit in Chartership with it being conference season and other commitments such as courses / projects. 
  • The value of Chartership in CPD and how regularly updating PPDP can help keep you focused on your goals.
  • The different methods people were using for recording progress and communicating with mentor - Word, Wikis, Email, Google Docs, Dropbox and PB works
  • Doing CDP23 in connection to Chartership and whether people follow the 23 weeks religiously or just dip in and out. It was commented that cpd23 could be used to show reflective practice (blog) and demonstrating use of new technology but that some people felt it was difficult to do both.
  • The value of local meet ups with other people doing Chartership, even if they are informal events.
  • A side topic on whether employers supported Chartership by offering increments (no one did!) and whether it was required for jobs.
I've been following the Chartership Chats almost since they began and although I haven't made every one I always find them a real motivator. It was no coincidence that my first participation also coincided with my Twitter debut as the chats were the main reason that I signed up.
The Chartership Chats demonstrate why you should be on Twitter. I don't know most of the people who participate in the chats and in some cases I will probably never meet them. Many come from different sectors to my own.  However I always learn something new, get some practical ideas and most importantly get a virtual kick up the back side to get some work done. It's a great opportunity to see how other people are attacking Chartership. Outside of the chats I continue to learn and share ideas with the people who participate.

If you are doing Chartership and aren't engaging with the profession on Twitter I really think you need to rethink your stance. Conferences and email lists can only be so current, Twitter is about the here and now and will enhance any experience, whether real or virtual - try searching CILIPARLG12 on Twitter of you want to see an example. 

Saturday, 30 June 2012

Weeding - A Vital Process For A Healthy Stock

There has been a lot of bad press recently for Manchester Public Libraries  clear out of it's archives and stored stock. I can sympathise as I've been having my own clear out at work (admittedly on a radically smaller scale) and it isn't always an easy process. For us it has has been made easier by our knowledgeable staff who can provide real feedback as to how the stock is used beyond the reports that can be produced from the LMS. 

Anyway the subject is a shameless excuse to post some pictures of some work from Easter - all made from recycled weeded stock. 




Public Lending Rights and E-Books

The Public Lending Right is the right for authors to receive payment for loans made through public libraries. In the UK the Public Lending Rights Act was passed in 1976 and the first payment to authors were made in 1984. In 2011-12 £6.5 million pounds was distributed to authors under the scheme at a rate of 6.05p per loan. 


Since learning about it I've always wondered how PLR was calculated prior to electronic LM systems were introduced. Apparently they use loan data from a sample of public libraries and I've often pondered on the man power involved in the early days. However, until recently PLR was not something that encroached on my practice much, especially not since I moved into academic libraries where the payments aren't made. However there has been a recent announcement regarding the future of PLR which did get my attention because it raised an interesting point about ebooks that had previously escaped my notice. The fact is that authors do not receive PLR payments for the loan of digital editions of their titles through public libraries even though the Digital Economy Act of 2010 makes provisions for these payments to be made. 


Now often when I talk about the issues associated with ebook lending in libraries I talk about publishers and their increasing coolness towards companies such as Overdrive. Although The Guardian says that The Society of Authors shares this coolness I can't help but wonder how much of an impact extending PLR to ebooks (and incidentally audio books) would have on their attitude. Despite the fact that PLR payments are never going to reach vast sums for individuals there seems something fundamentally wrong about not paying authors for digital loans. If I was an author, watching digital sales climb I wound certainly be wondering about the impact on my PLR payments and questioning the refusal of the DCMS to implement it. I certainly wouldn't be putting any pressure on my publisher to allow e-lending if I knew I wasn't going to receive remuneration for the loans.


This said there is the case (in my opinion a flawed case) that including e-loans and audio books in PLR calculations wouldn't have any noticeable effect. It goes like this:

  • As the DCMS has been cutting the PLRs budget, there is no guarantee that including elending and ABs would result in an increase of this budget. I'm not saying that is right but it is a reasonable conclusion.
  • This means the same budget would be split more ways resulting in a smaller price paid per loan. 
  • If you assume that physical lending and elending statistics are equivalent  and that people borrow the same audio books as real books then incorporating e-loans serves no purpose. Proportionally the figures would stay the same.
The problem with this is that we know that physical lending and e lending is not equivalent, if only because so many publishers refuse to engage with libraries over e-lending. The difference between audio books and physical books must be even larger given the tiny proportion of non fiction books published in audio format. So introducing ABs and EBs into the PLR might mean a shift in the payments received by authors. It might also encourage authors to think more positively about e-lending in libraries.


PLR for Ebooks is only a small part of a large problem when it comes to e lending in libraries but given that the DEA 2010 provides for it there seems no excuse for not making amendments to the appropriate legislation, even if no extra money is available. However if it is to happen we certainly need a functioning PLR registrar and it is exactly this that the DCMS seems to be trying to do away with. So if you believe that PLR is important, for any type of book, why not respond to the consultation currently underway on PLR Functions and Funding and try and stop it being absorbed into another organisation.